We just wrapped up our 2026 Enlist E3 Soybean Test Plot here at Maranatha Acres on October 9. This year’s plot included 17 entries from several seed companies, planted side-by-side to compare how different varieties performed under our farm management

With fluctuating weather throughout the summer and a wet finish to the season, we were curious to see how these soybeans would finish and what the final yields would look like. We were also interested to see how the results compared with the Plenish Enlist E3 soybeans we grew elsewhere on the farm. We thought we might see some yield drag with those, but this year they finished right in line with what we were seeing in the Enlist E3 test plot, which was encouraging.

One question we’ve continued evaluating in our test plots over the past couple of years is whether treated soybean seed provides enough of a yield advantage to justify the additional cost.

This year’s results gave us more information to consider, along with some familiar names near the top of the rankings and a few interesting comparisons across maturity groups.

By collecting our own on-farm data, we can make better-informed seed decisions for the coming seasons. These results help us evaluate genetics, compare maturity groups, and understand how different varieties perform in our Northwest Ohio soils.

Test Plot Overview

Our 2026 soybean plot was planted on May 14 near Delta, Ohio, on variable sandy loam soil. The field was previously planted to corn, with residue managed through conventional tillage. A rye cover crop was used on the sand hills to help cut down on wind erosion during the winter months. It was terminated in early spring prior to planting.

The plot covered approximately 7.8 acres and included 16 different varieties, with a repeated checker throughout the plot. The soybeans were planted in 30-inch rows at a target seeding rate of 125,000 seeds per acre. We also applied 6.5 gallons per acre of 10-34-0 in a 2-by-2 placement at planting – note that this is the only phosphorus we apply to our soybean crop.

The plot length was 1,149 feet, and each variety was planted in six rows. The lineup included early-season varieties ranging from 2.3 to 2.7 relative maturity (RM) and full-season varieties ranging from 2.8 to 3.3 RM.

As in previous years, we divided the results into early-season and full-season comparisons. This lets us evaluate varieties within their maturity groups instead of relying solely on one overall ranking. For each comparison, yields were adjusted using the checker rows in that section.

Harvest took place on October 9, 2026. The report includes actual yields, check-adjusted yields, harvest moisture, and separate rankings for the overall, early-season, and full-season plots.

Overhead Shot of the Test plot

Key Findings from the 2026 Soybean Test Plot

Top-Yielding Varieties

HiSoy® HS29E60 led the overall plot with a check-adjusted yield of 71.24 bushels per acre. Pioneer® P25A16E followed closely, and the untreated version of Pioneer® P28Z89E rounded out the top three.

Here are the top five entries in the overall plot:

  1. HiSoy® HS29E60 — 71.24 bu/acre: Finished first overall, with an actual yield of 69.9 bu/acre.
  2. Pioneer® P25A16E — 69.54 bu/acre: Finished second overall and led the early-season plot.
  3. Pioneer® P28Z89E (Untreated) — 68.44 bu/acre: Finished third overall and provided one of our two treated-versus-untreated comparisons.
  4. Pioneer® P28Z89E (Treated) — 67.14 bu/acre: Finished fourth overall, close behind the untreated entry.
  5. Connect® CT2725E — 66.84 bu/acre: Finished fifth overall and second in the early-season comparison.

One important detail when reviewing these numbers is that actual yield and check-adjusted yield are not the same. Actual yield is the harvested yield recorded for an entry. Check-adjusted yield accounts for differences in the checker rows closest to each variety, helping us compare performance across the plot.

This year, we used repeated checker rows of Xitavo® XO 2556E throughout the plot to help account for field variability. The adjustments are especially useful in a field like this one with variable soils, where differences in yield may reflect more than just the genetics being tested.

Check-adjusted yield is our primary metric for ranking varieties, but actual yield, maturity, disease characteristics, and previous performance all factor into our decisions.

Early-Season Standouts

Pioneer® P25A16E led the early-season plot with a check-adjusted yield of 67.25 bushels per acre. Connect® CT2725E followed at 64.55 bushels per acre, with Pioneer® P23Z82E third at 64.05 bushels per acre.

The top three early-season entries were:

  1. Pioneer® P25A16E — 67.25 bu/acre
  2. Connect® CT2725E — 64.55 bu/acre
  3. Pioneer® P23Z82E — 64.05 bu/acre

P25A16E’s performance was particularly interesting because it wasn’t just a strong early-season performer. It also finished second overall in the full plot.

Pioneer® P25A16E: A Three-Year Performer

Pioneer® P25A16E is becoming a variety that seems to perform no matter the year. It has performed well in our trials for 3+ consecutive years. In the two previous years, we used this variety as our checker because of its consistent performance on our farm.

Here’s how it has ranked in our plots:

YearOverall plot rankEarly-season plot rank
20243rd1st
20253rd2nd
20262nd1st

In 2026, P25A16E produced a check-adjusted yield of 69.54 bushels per acre in the overall plot and 67.25 bushels per acre in the early-season comparison.

What makes that record interesting is the consistency. It hasn’t just had one good year; it continues to be near the top of our rankings while competing against newer genetics and other seed companies’ lineups in successive seasons.

P25A16E has a 2.5 relative maturity and is described as having high yield potential, with good ratings for white mold, sudden death syndrome (SDS), and frogeye leaf spot.

Of course, past performance doesn’t guarantee future results, and variety rankings can change with weather and field conditions. But if you are looking for a reasonably priced soybean that continues to perform year over year, this one is a good one to look at.

There’s also a good reminder here about variety selection in general. New numbers are always coming to market, but an older variety that continues to perform shouldn’t be overlooked just because something newer is available. P25A16E should be considered as you plan for the 2027 growing season.

Full-Season Performers

HiSoy® HS29E60 led the full-season plot with a check-adjusted yield of 72.77 bushels per acre. Pioneer® P28Z89E followed in both its untreated and treated versions.

The top three full-season entries were:

  1. HiSoy® HS29E60 — 72.77 bu/acre
  2. Pioneer® P28Z89E (Untreated) — 69.97 bu/acre
  3. Pioneer® P28Z89E (Treated) — 68.67 bu/acre

HiSoy® HS29E60 was the leading entry in both the overall and full-season comparisons. Its supplied variety information highlights upgraded SDS tolerance and identifies it as a variety that can be planted across a range of conditions.

Pioneer® P28Z89E also has an interesting history in our plots.

Pioneer® P28Z89E: Another Variety With a Strong Track Record

Our previous plot records show that P28Z89E ranked second overall and third in the late-season comparison in 2024. In 2025, it moved to first overall and first in the late-season plot.

In 2026, it again performed well. The untreated entry finished third overall, while the treated entry finished fourth. In the full-season comparison, they ranked second and third, respectively.

The variety has a relative maturity of 2.8, and its supplied characteristics highlight strong white mold and SDS ratings. It’s also identified as a fit for productive soils.

P28Z89E is another example of why we continue to pay attention to varieties that have already proven themselves in our own plots. We planted this number on some acres last year and were impressed with how it performed from planting to harvest. 

This year’s treated vs. untreated comparison adds another layer to the story. The untreated entry had a higher check-adjusted yield, although the treated entry’s actual yield was slightly higher.

Let’s look at that comparison in more detail.

Case IH 2366 Running our Soybean Plot

Soybean Seed Treatment vs. Untreated Seed: What Did We Learn?

One of the most useful parts of this year’s plot was comparing treated and untreated versions of two of the entries in this year’s plot.

With seed costs remaining an important consideration, we want to understand whether the additional investment in seed treatment delivers a measurable benefit under our farm’s conditions.

Here is how the two comparisons turned out.

Pioneer® P28Z89E

MeasurementUntreatedTreated
Actual yield67.1 bu/acre67.3 bu/acre
Check-adjusted yield69.97 bu/acre68.67 bu/acre
Overall plot rank3rd4th
Full-season plot rank2nd3rd

The treated entry produced 0.2 bushels per acre more in actual yield. However, after adjusting for the nearby checker rows, the untreated entry finished 1.30 bushels per acre ahead.

Pioneer® P32Z91E

MeasurementUntreatedTreated
Actual yield69.3 bu/acre66.3 bu/acre
Check-adjusted yield65.07 bu/acre62.07 bu/acre
Overall plot rank13th15th
Full-season plot rank8th9th

For P32Z91E, the untreated entry finished 3.0 bushels per acre ahead in check-adjusted yield and also produced 3.0 bushels per acre more in actual yield.

Across both comparisons, the untreated entries finished ahead in check-adjusted yield. But what does that mean financially?

What Did Seed Treatment Cost Us in 2026?

To put these results into perspective, we calculated the economics using a soybean price of $12.50 per bushel and an estimated seed treatment cost of $18–$24 per unit. Each unit contains 140,000 seeds, and at our seeding rate of 125,000 seeds per acre, one unit covers approximately 1.12 acres.

That puts the additional treatment cost at approximately 16.07–21.43 per acre. At $12.50 soybeans, the treatment would need to deliver an additional 1.29–1.71 bushels per acre just to cover that cost.

Here’s how the two comparisons worked out using check-adjusted yield:

MeasurementP28Z89EP32Z91E
Untreated yield advantage1.30 bu/acre3.00 bu/acre
Value of yield difference at $12.50/bu$16.25/acre$37.50/acre
Estimated treatment cost16.07–21.43/acre16.07–21.43/acre
Treated seed’s net return vs. untreated−32.32-37.68/acre−53.57-58.93/acre

For P28Z89E, the untreated entry’s 1.30-bushel advantage was worth $16.25 per acre. Once we account for the added treatment cost, the treated entry’s net return was approximately 32.32–37.68 per acre lower than the untreated entry, based on check-adjusted yield.

The difference was larger with P32Z91E. Its untreated entry finished 3.0 bushels per acre ahead, representing $37.50 per acre in additional crop value. After accounting for treatment cost, the treated entry’s net return was approximately 53.57–58.93 per acre lower.

These calculations compare the economic outcomes of the treated and untreated entries in our plot. They don’t prove that treatment itself caused the yield differences, but they show how quickly the economics can change when a yield advantage doesn’t materialize.

When Does Seed Treatment Pay?

Our current thinking is that seed treatment may provide its greatest value when we’re pushing early planting windows and putting seed into colder soils. Under those conditions, protection against the risks targeted by a treatment may be more valuable.

When we’re able to wait for more favorable planting conditions and soil temperatures, the return may be less certain. However, we also ran a treated-vs. untreated comparison on another farm where the treated seed came out ahead, even though planting conditions were favorable.

That result is another reason we’re not ready to draw a firm conclusion about when treatment pays. The value depends on the product used, its cost, the risks present at planting, and the conditions each crop encounters.

It’s also important to remember that these comparisons represent a limited number of varieties and field conditions. We can’t use them to conclude that seed treatment never pays, or that the results would be the same under a different planting date or environment.

Still, the comparisons give us useful information. When we’re deciding where to spend our input dollars, we want to look at the data and determine whether the additional cost is worth it on our operation or not.

We’ll continue testing treated and untreated seed to see whether the results change across planting dates, soil conditions, and growing seasons. Ultimately, we want to know not just whether treatment can help pay for itself but if there are any yield advantages. 

Overhead view of the Combine combining soybeans

Harvest Moisture: An Interesting Finish to the Season

Harvest moisture with soybeans is always a critical statistic we monitor during harvest. This year, the harvest moisture got our attention. The moisture values from across the plot ranged from 10.1% to 12.1% across the entries.

Even though we had several drying windows, our soybeans never dropped below 10% moisture in this plot—or on any of the other farms we harvested. That was interesting to see across varieties ranging from 2.3 to 3.3 relative maturity.

Maturity is one consideration when comparing soybean varieties, but these results show that even the earlier entries did not fall below that moisture threshold in our 2026 harvest.

Of course, this reflects one season and one set of field conditions. We wouldn’t use it to predict dry-down performance in every year.

Peking Varieties and SCN Management

Soybean cyst nematode (SCN) remains an important consideration in our soybean variety-selection process, particularly in the sandier soils across our operation. You can see in the image below that this plot had quite a bit of lighter soil types in it.

Over the past several seasons, we’ve almost exclusively planted soybeans with Peking resistance, with the exception of some of our heavier soil types. The last two years, we’ve leaned especially heavily on Peking varieties because of the amount of SCN pressure we face in our soils.

Hoegemeyer® 3185E: A Different Resistance Source in the Top 7

One result that stood out to us was Hoegemeyer® 3185E, which finished fourth in the full-season comparison with a check-adjusted yield of 68.07 bushels per acre and sixth in the full plot.

This variety uses the PI 88788 SCN resistance source. We’ve relied heavily on Peking varieties in recent test plots, and we haven’t had a non-Peking entry finish in our top 10 for a while. That made 3185E an entry worth paying attention to.

Its result is a reminder that we should continue evaluating varieties with different resistance sources rather than assuming one characteristic will determine yield performance.

Still, yield performance combined with resistance characteristics gives us useful information when deciding which varieties deserve consideration for future seasons. For fields with a history of SCN issues, we’ll continue to consider resistance characteristics alongside yield performance rather than choosing a variety based on yield alone.

Soil type map from Acres.com

Looking Ahead: Applying What We’ve Learned

As we start thinking about the 2027 growing season, there are a few things from this year’s plot that stand out.

Consistency matters. Pioneer® P25A16E has finished near the top of our rankings for three consecutive years, including first in the early-season plot in both 2024 and 2026. Pioneer® P28Z89E has also continued to perform well. Sometimes the newer varieties get most of the attention, but our results are a good reminder that older numbers can still be competitive. The Z-series varieties have earned a strong reputation, and our own plot data gives us another reason to keep them in the conversation.

Seed treatment is still a question we’re working through. Both treated vs. untreated comparisons favored the untreated entries on check-adjusted yield this year. However, we also ran a treated vs. untreated comparison on another farm where the treated seed came out ahead, even though planting conditions were favorable. That reinforces why we don’t want to draw a broad conclusion from one plot or one set of conditions. We’ll keep testing to better understand when the added cost makes sense.

Different resistance traits deserve attention alongside yield. Hoegemeyer® 3185E was one of the more interesting entries this year. It finished fourth in the full-season comparison despite using the PI 88788 SCN resistance source rather than Peking. We’ve leaned heavily on Peking varieties because of the SCN pressure we face, so seeing 3185E perform that well gives us another option worth evaluating. 

The season didn’t quite finish where we hoped. We had enough moisture through August and September that we expected yields to be a little higher in this plot. While we had some strong individual performers, the overall results left us a little disappointed. That’s part of farming: we make the best decisions we can with the information available, then use the results to improve our decisions for the next season.

Ultimately, our goal isn’t just to identify the winner in a single year’s plot. We want to learn which varieties consistently perform in our soils, how different management decisions affect results, and where our input dollars provide the best return. Each year adds another piece to that picture.

Conclusion

Our 2026 soybean test plot gave us another year of local data to use when selecting varieties and evaluating management decisions at Maranatha Acres. From the continued performance of P25A16E and P28Z89E to the seed treatment comparisons and Hoegemeyer® 3185E’s results, there are several findings we’ll carry into next season.

We appreciate the seed companies that participated and the opportunity to keep testing varieties side-by-side under our own farm conditions. We’ll continue sharing our results as we look for ways to improve crop performance and make informed decisions for the seasons ahead.

Want to dig into the numbers? Download the complete 2026 Enlist E3 Soybean Test Plot report to see the overall, early-season, and full-season rankings, along with actual yields and harvest moisture.